filter-graph: remove the pipe filter

It's a terrible idea, doesn't work so well (locks up the data-loop when
read is blocked) and a security mightmare. If you really need to pipe
samples through some program, do that somewhere else, like from the
command line with pw-cat and pw-record.
This commit is contained in:
Wim Taymans 2026-05-08 10:16:12 +02:00
parent b3257ae425
commit 5b37b9cf99
6 changed files with 1 additions and 438 deletions

View file

@ -76,14 +76,6 @@ spa_filter_graph_plugin_builtin = shared_library('spa-filter-graph-plugin-builti
objects : audioconvert_c.extract_objects('biquad.c')
)
spa_filter_graph_plugin_pipe = shared_library('spa-filter-graph-plugin-pipe',
[ 'plugin_pipe.c' ],
include_directories : [configinc],
install : true,
install_dir : spa_plugindir / 'filter-graph',
dependencies : [ filter_graph_dependencies ],
)
spa_filter_graph_plugin_ladspa = shared_library('spa-filter-graph-plugin-ladspa',
[ 'plugin_ladspa.c' ],
include_directories : [configinc],

View file

@ -1,387 +0,0 @@
#include "config.h"
#include <limits.h>
#include <fcntl.h>
#include <sys/wait.h>
#include <spa/utils/json.h>
#include <spa/support/log.h>
#include <spa/utils/cleanup.h>
#include "audio-plugin.h"
struct plugin {
struct spa_handle handle;
struct spa_fga_plugin plugin;
struct spa_log *log;
};
/* pipe */
struct pipe_impl {
struct plugin *plugin;
struct spa_log *log;
unsigned long rate;
float *port[3];
float latency;
int write_fd;
int read_fd;
size_t written;
size_t read;
};
static int do_exec(struct pipe_impl *impl, const char *command)
{
int pid, res, len, argc = 0;
char *argv[512];
struct spa_json it[2];
const char *value;
int stdin_pipe[2];
int stdout_pipe[2];
if (spa_json_begin_array_relax(&it[0], command, strlen(command)) <= 0)
return -EINVAL;
while ((len = spa_json_next(&it[0], &value)) > 0) {
char *s;
if (argc >= (int)SPA_N_ELEMENTS(argv) - 1) {
spa_log_error(impl->log, "too many exec arguments");
res = -E2BIG;
goto error_argv;
}
if ((s = malloc(len+1)) == NULL) {
res = -errno;
goto error_argv;
}
spa_json_parse_stringn(value, len, s, len+1);
argv[argc++] = s;
}
argv[argc++] = NULL;
if (pipe2(stdin_pipe, 0) < 0) {
res = -errno;
spa_log_error(impl->log, "pipe2 error: %m");
goto error_argv;
}
if (pipe2(stdout_pipe, 0) < 0) {
res = -errno;
spa_log_error(impl->log, "pipe2 error: %m");
close(stdin_pipe[0]);
close(stdin_pipe[1]);
goto error_argv;
}
impl->write_fd = stdin_pipe[1];
impl->read_fd = stdout_pipe[0];
pid = fork();
if (pid == 0) {
char buf[1024];
char *const *p;
struct spa_strbuf s;
/* Double fork to avoid zombies; we don't want to set SIGCHLD handler */
pid = fork();
if (pid < 0) {
spa_log_error(impl->log, "fork error: %m");
goto done;
} else if (pid != 0) {
exit(0);
}
dup2(stdin_pipe[0], 0);
dup2(stdout_pipe[1], 1);
spa_strbuf_init(&s, buf, sizeof(buf));
for (p = argv; *p; ++p)
spa_strbuf_append(&s, " '%s'", *p);
spa_log_info(impl->log, "exec%s", s.buffer);
res = execvp(argv[0], argv);
if (res == -1) {
res = -errno;
spa_log_error(impl->log, "execvp error '%s': %m", argv[0]);
}
done:
exit(1);
} else if (pid < 0) {
spa_log_error(impl->log, "fork error: %m");
} else {
int status = 0;
close(stdin_pipe[0]);
close(stdout_pipe[1]);
do {
errno = 0;
res = waitpid(pid, &status, 0);
} while (res < 0 && errno == EINTR);
spa_log_debug(impl->log, "exec got pid %d res:%d status:%d", (int)pid, res, status);
}
res = 0;
error_argv:
while (argc > 0)
free(argv[--argc]);
return res;
}
static void pipe_transfer(struct pipe_impl *impl, float *in, float *out, int count)
{
ssize_t sz;
sz = read(impl->read_fd, out, count * sizeof(float));
if (sz > 0) {
impl->read += sz;
if (impl->read == (size_t)sz) {
while ((sz = read(impl->read_fd, out, count * sizeof(float))) != -1)
impl->read += sz;
}
} else {
memset(out, 0, count * sizeof(float));
}
if ((sz = write(impl->write_fd, in, count * sizeof(float))) != -1)
impl->written += sz;
}
static void *pipe_instantiate(const struct spa_fga_plugin *plugin, const struct spa_fga_descriptor * Descriptor,
unsigned long SampleRate, int index, const char *config)
{
struct plugin *pl = SPA_CONTAINER_OF(plugin, struct plugin, plugin);
struct pipe_impl *impl;
struct spa_json it[2];
const char *val;
char key[256];
spa_autofree char*command = NULL;
int len;
errno = EINVAL;
if (config == NULL) {
spa_log_error(pl->log, "pipe: requires a config section");
return NULL;
}
if (spa_json_begin_object(&it[0], config, strlen(config)) <= 0) {
spa_log_error(pl->log, "pipe: config must be an object");
return NULL;
}
while ((len = spa_json_object_next(&it[0], key, sizeof(key), &val)) > 0) {
if (spa_streq(key, "command")) {
if ((command = malloc(len+1)) == NULL)
return NULL;
if (spa_json_parse_stringn(val, len, command, len+1) <= 0) {
spa_log_error(pl->log, "pipe: command requires a string");
return NULL;
}
}
else {
spa_log_warn(pl->log, "pipe: ignoring config key: '%s'", key);
}
}
if (command == NULL || command[0] == '\0') {
spa_log_error(pl->log, "pipe: command must be given and can not be empty");
return NULL;
}
impl = calloc(1, sizeof(*impl));
if (impl == NULL)
return NULL;
impl->plugin = pl;
impl->log = pl->log;
impl->rate = SampleRate;
do_exec(impl, command);
int flags;
if ((flags = fcntl(impl->write_fd, F_GETFL)) >= 0)
fcntl(impl->write_fd, F_SETFL, flags | O_NONBLOCK);
if ((flags = fcntl(impl->read_fd, F_GETFL)) >= 0)
fcntl(impl->read_fd, F_SETFL, flags | O_NONBLOCK);
return impl;
}
static void pipe_connect_port(void *Instance, unsigned long Port, void * DataLocation)
{
struct pipe_impl *impl = Instance;
impl->port[Port] = DataLocation;
}
static void pipe_run(void * Instance, unsigned long SampleCount)
{
struct pipe_impl *impl = Instance;
float *in = impl->port[0], *out = impl->port[1];
if (in != NULL && out != NULL)
pipe_transfer(impl, in, out, SampleCount);
}
static void pipe_cleanup(void * Instance)
{
struct pipe_impl *impl = Instance;
close(impl->write_fd);
close(impl->read_fd);
free(impl);
}
static struct spa_fga_port pipe_ports[] = {
{ .index = 0,
.name = "In",
.flags = SPA_FGA_PORT_INPUT | SPA_FGA_PORT_AUDIO,
},
{ .index = 1,
.name = "Out",
.flags = SPA_FGA_PORT_OUTPUT | SPA_FGA_PORT_AUDIO,
},
};
static const struct spa_fga_descriptor pipe_desc = {
.name = "pipe",
.flags = SPA_FGA_DESCRIPTOR_SUPPORTS_NULL_DATA,
.n_ports = SPA_N_ELEMENTS(pipe_ports),
.ports = pipe_ports,
.instantiate = pipe_instantiate,
.connect_port = pipe_connect_port,
.run = pipe_run,
.cleanup = pipe_cleanup,
};
static const struct spa_fga_descriptor * pipe_descriptor(unsigned long Index)
{
switch(Index) {
case 0:
return &pipe_desc;
}
return NULL;
}
static const struct spa_fga_descriptor *pipe_plugin_make_desc(void *plugin, const char *name)
{
unsigned long i;
for (i = 0; ;i++) {
const struct spa_fga_descriptor *d = pipe_descriptor(i);
if (d == NULL)
break;
if (spa_streq(d->name, name))
return d;
}
return NULL;
}
static struct spa_fga_plugin_methods impl_plugin = {
SPA_VERSION_FGA_PLUGIN_METHODS,
.make_desc = pipe_plugin_make_desc,
};
static int impl_get_interface(struct spa_handle *handle, const char *type, void **interface)
{
struct plugin *impl;
spa_return_val_if_fail(handle != NULL, -EINVAL);
spa_return_val_if_fail(interface != NULL, -EINVAL);
impl = (struct plugin *) handle;
if (spa_streq(type, SPA_TYPE_INTERFACE_FILTER_GRAPH_AudioPlugin))
*interface = &impl->plugin;
else
return -ENOENT;
return 0;
}
static int impl_clear(struct spa_handle *handle)
{
return 0;
}
static size_t
impl_get_size(const struct spa_handle_factory *factory,
const struct spa_dict *params)
{
return sizeof(struct plugin);
}
static int
impl_init(const struct spa_handle_factory *factory,
struct spa_handle *handle,
const struct spa_dict *info,
const struct spa_support *support,
uint32_t n_support)
{
struct plugin *impl;
handle->get_interface = impl_get_interface;
handle->clear = impl_clear;
impl = (struct plugin *) handle;
impl->plugin.iface = SPA_INTERFACE_INIT(
SPA_TYPE_INTERFACE_FILTER_GRAPH_AudioPlugin,
SPA_VERSION_FGA_PLUGIN,
&impl_plugin, impl);
impl->log = spa_support_find(support, n_support, SPA_TYPE_INTERFACE_Log);
return 0;
}
static const struct spa_interface_info impl_interfaces[] = {
{SPA_TYPE_INTERFACE_FILTER_GRAPH_AudioPlugin,},
};
static int
impl_enum_interface_info(const struct spa_handle_factory *factory,
const struct spa_interface_info **info,
uint32_t *index)
{
spa_return_val_if_fail(factory != NULL, -EINVAL);
spa_return_val_if_fail(info != NULL, -EINVAL);
spa_return_val_if_fail(index != NULL, -EINVAL);
switch (*index) {
case 0:
*info = &impl_interfaces[*index];
break;
default:
return 0;
}
(*index)++;
return 1;
}
static struct spa_handle_factory spa_fga_pipe_plugin_factory = {
SPA_VERSION_HANDLE_FACTORY,
"filter.graph.plugin.pipe",
NULL,
impl_get_size,
impl_init,
impl_enum_interface_info,
};
SPA_EXPORT
int spa_handle_factory_enum(const struct spa_handle_factory **factory, uint32_t *index)
{
spa_return_val_if_fail(factory != NULL, -EINVAL);
spa_return_val_if_fail(index != NULL, -EINVAL);
switch (*index) {
case 0:
*factory = &spa_fga_pipe_plugin_factory;
break;
default:
return 0;
}
(*index)++;
return 1;
}

View file

@ -86,7 +86,6 @@ context.spa-libs = {
#audio.aec = aec/libspa-aec-webrtc
#filter.graph.plugin.ffmpeg = filter-graph/libspa-filter-graph-plugin-ffmpeg
#filter.graph.plugin.onnx = filter-graph/libspa-filter-graph-plugin-onnx
#filter.graph.plugin.pipe = blocked
#filter.graph.plugin.ebur128 = filter-graph/libspa-filter-graph-plugin-ebur128
#filter.graph.plugin.sofa = filter-graph/libspa-filter-graph-plugin-sofa
#filter.graph.plugin.ladspa = filter-graph/libspa-filter-graph-plugin-ladspa

View file

@ -30,8 +30,6 @@ context.spa-libs = {
# inside the server, we must be careful with the filter-graph.
#filter.graph.plugin.ffmpeg = filter-graph/libspa-filter-graph-plugin-ffmpeg
#filter.graph.plugin.onnx = filter-graph/libspa-filter-graph-plugin-onnx
#filter.graph.plugin.pipe = filter-graph/libspa-filter-graph-plugin-pipe
filter.graph.plugin.pipe = blocked
#filter.graph.plugin.ebur128 = filter-graph/libspa-filter-graph-plugin-ebur128
#filter.graph.plugin.sofa = filter-graph/libspa-filter-graph-plugin-sofa
filter.graph.plugin.ladspa = filter-graph/libspa-filter-graph-plugin-ladspa

View file

@ -91,8 +91,6 @@ context.spa-libs = {
audio.aec = aec/libspa-aec-webrtc
#filter.graph.plugin.ffmpeg = filter-graph/libspa-filter-graph-plugin-ffmpeg
filter.graph.plugin.onnx = filter-graph/libspa-filter-graph-plugin-onnx
#filter.graph.plugin.pipe = filter-graph/libspa-filter-graph-plugin-pipe
filter.graph.plugin.pipe = blocked
filter.graph.plugin.ebur128 = filter-graph/libspa-filter-graph-plugin-ebur128
filter.graph.plugin.sofa = filter-graph/libspa-filter-graph-plugin-sofa
filter.graph.plugin.ladspa = filter-graph/libspa-filter-graph-plugin-ladspa

View file

@ -96,7 +96,7 @@ extern struct spa_handle_factory spa_filter_graph_factory;
* Nodes describe the processing filters in the graph. Use a tool like lv2ls
* or listplugins to get a list of available plugins, labels and the port names.
*
* - `type` is one of `ladspa`, `lv2`, `builtin`, `pipe`, `sofa`, `ebur128` of `ffmpeg`.
* - `type` is one of `ladspa`, `lv2`, `builtin`, `sofa`, `ebur128` of `ffmpeg`.
* - `name` is the name for this node, you might need this later to refer to this node
* and its ports when setting controls or making links.
* - `plugin` is the type specific plugin name.
@ -706,43 +706,6 @@ extern struct spa_handle_factory spa_filter_graph_factory;
* The `null` plugin has one data input "In" and one control input "Control" that
* simply discards the data.
*
* ## PIPE filters
*
* There is a `pipe` type available. This filter is sometimes blocked because it can load
* arbitrary programs.
*
* ### Pipe
*
* The `pipe` plugin can be used to filter the audio with another application using pipes
* for sending and receiving the raw audio.
*
* The application needs to consume raw float32 samples from stdin and produce filtered
* float32 samples on stdout.
*
* It has an "In" input port and an "Out" output data ports.
*
* The node requires a `config` section with extra configuration:
*
*\code{.unparsed}
* filter.graph = {
* nodes = [
* {
* type = pipe
* name = ...
* label = pipe
* config = {
* command = "ffmpeg -f f32le -ac 1 -ar 48000 -blocksize 1024 -fflags nobuffer -i \"pipe:\" \"-filter:a\" \"loudnorm=I=-18:TP=-3:LRA=4\" -f f32le -ac 1 -ar 48000 \"pipe:\""
* }
* ...
* }
* }
* ...
* }
*\endcode
*
* - `command` the command to execute. It should consume samples from stdin and produce
* samples on stdout.
*
* ## SOFA filters
*
* There is an optional `sofa` type available (when compiled with `libmysofa`).