libinput/doc/user/clickpad-with-right-button.rst
Peter Hutterer a7e4cbc212 quirks: allow overriding of AttrEventCode and AttrInputProp
This switches the quirk from AttrEventCodeEnable/Disable to just
AttrEventCode with a +/- prefix for each entry.
This switches the quirk from AttrInputPropEnable/Disable to just
AttrInputProp with a +/- prefix for each entry.

Previously, both event codes and input props would only apply the
last-matching section entry for a device. Furthermore, an earlier Disable entry
would take precedence over a later Enable entry. For example, a set of
sections with these lines *should* enable left, right and middle:

  [first]
  AttrEventCodeEnable=BTN_LEFT;BTN_RIGHT;BTN_MIDDLE

  [second]
  AttrEventCodeDisable=BTN_RIGHT

  [third]
  AttrEventCodeEnable=BTN_LEFT;BTN_RIGHT;

Alas: the first line was effectively ignored (quirks only returned the
last-matching one, i.e. the one from "third"). And due to implementation
details in evdev.c, the Disable attribute was processed after Enable,
i.e. the device was enabled for left + right and then disabled for
right. As a result, the device only had BTN_LEFT enabled.

Fix this by changing the attribute to carry both enable/disable
information and merging the commands together.

Internally, all quirks matching a device are simply ref'd into an array
in the struct quirks. The applied value is simply the last entry in the
array corresponding to our quirk.

For AttrEventCode and AttrInputProp instead do this:
- switch them to a tuple with the code as first entry and a boolean
  enable/disable as second entry
- if the struct quirk already has an entry for either, append the more
  recent one to the existing entry (instead of creating a new entry in
  the array). This way we have all entries that match and in-order of
  precedence - i.e. we can process them left-to-right to end up
  with the right state.

Fixes: https://gitlab.freedesktop.org/libinput/libinput/-/issues/821

Signed-off-by: Peter Hutterer <peter.hutterer@who-t.net>
2022-11-28 08:25:41 +10:00

47 lines
2.4 KiB
ReStructuredText

.. _clickpads_with_right_buttons:
==============================================================================
Clickpads with a fake right button
==============================================================================
libinput relies on the kernel to label :ref:`Clickpads <touchpads_buttons_clickpads>`
with the ``INPUT_PROP_BUTTONPAD`` property so it can enable the correct
:ref:`clickpad_softbuttons`. Clickpads are not expected to have a right button
since the whole surface can be depressed.
A common bug encountered with :ref:`Clickpads <touchpads_buttons_clickpads>`
is that the device advertises a physical right button where no such button
exists. This is usually a bug in the firmware of the device and causes the
following warning to be emitted by libinput::
"<device name> clickpad advertising right button"
The user-visible effect of this is usually negligible since these devices
cannot actually trigger a right click and libinput's default behaviors for
clickpads work as expected.
However, we should nonetheless correct the device to get rid of this warning
and avoid potential issues with future features. The :ref:`device-quirks`
provide a simple way to disable the fake right button on the device. The
following quirk disables the right button on the MyModel laptop from the
MyVendor OEM::
[MyVendor MyModel Touchpad]
MatchName=Foo Bar Touchpad
MatchUdevtype=touchpad
MatchDMIModAlias=dmi:*svnMyVendor:pnMyModel:*
AttrEventCode=-BTN_RIGHT
The name of the device can be obtained using :ref:`libinput record <libinput-record>`,
the modalias match is a shell-style glob against the value of ``/sys/class/dmi/id/modalias``.
In most cases, matching should be against ``svn`` (system vendor) and one of
``pn`` (product name) or ``pvr`` (product version), whichever provides a
useful description of the individual laptop model. See the
:ref:`device-quirks` documentation for details on testing local quirks.
For reference, some example commits that add such a quirk are:
- `bf61ab9bb0694d0ac3d60a7f815779abfe4886e6 <https://gitlab.freedesktop.org/libinput/libinput/-/commit/bf61ab9bb0694d0ac3d60a7f815779abfe4886e6>`__
- `74fac6d040ac62048882dfb6f73da567ace6a6f5 <https://gitlab.freedesktop.org/libinput/libinput/-/commit/74fac6d040ac62048882dfb6f73da567ace6a6f5>`__
- `89cd0f990e3bee9906754d6ca8484ed5aa392249 <https://gitlab.freedesktop.org/libinput/libinput/-/commit/89cd0f990e3bee9906754d6ca8484ed5aa392249>`__