dbus/doc/TODO

150 lines
5.9 KiB
Text
Raw Normal View History

Important for 1.0
===
- change .service files to have Names=list rather than Name=string
- How we will handle DCOP needs sorting out. Among other things, we
need to check that service and service-ownership semantics map to DCOP
reasonably well.
- Activation needs some careful additional thinking-through.
- Audit @todo and FIXME for security issues
- The convenience functions in dbus-bus.h should perhaps have
the signatures that they would have if they were autogenerated
stubs. e.g. the acquire service function. We should also evaluate
which of these functions to include, in light of the fact that
GLib/Qt native stubs will probably also exist.
2005-01-15 Havoc Pennington <hp@redhat.com> * Land the new message args API and type system. This patch is huge, but the public API change is not really large. The set of D-BUS types has changed somewhat, and the arg "getters" are more geared toward language bindings; they don't make a copy, etc. There are also some known issues. See these emails for details on this huge patch: http://lists.freedesktop.org/archives/dbus/2004-December/001836.html http://lists.freedesktop.org/archives/dbus/2005-January/001922.html * dbus/dbus-marshal-*: all the new stuff * dbus/dbus-message.c: basically rewritten * dbus/dbus-memory.c (check_guards): with "guards" enabled, init freed blocks to be all non-nul bytes so using freed memory is less likely to work right * dbus/dbus-internals.c (_dbus_test_oom_handling): add DBUS_FAIL_MALLOC=N environment variable, so you can do DBUS_FAIL_MALLOC=0 to skip the out-of-memory checking, or DBUS_FAIL_MALLOC=10 to make it really, really, really slow and thorough. * qt/message.cpp: port to the new message args API (operator<<): use str.utf8() rather than str.unicode() (pretty sure this is right from the Qt docs?) * glib/dbus-gvalue.c: port to the new message args API * bus/dispatch.c, bus/driver.c: port to the new message args API * dbus/dbus-string.c (_dbus_string_init_const_len): initialize the "locked" flag to TRUE and align_offset to 0; I guess we never looked at these anyhow, but seems cleaner. * dbus/dbus-string.h (_DBUS_STRING_ALLOCATION_PADDING): move allocation padding macro to this header; use it to implement (_DBUS_STRING_STATIC): ability to declare a static string. * dbus/dbus-message.c (_dbus_message_has_type_interface_member): change to return TRUE if the interface is not set. * dbus/dbus-string.[hc]: move the D-BUS specific validation stuff to dbus-marshal-validate.[hc] * dbus/dbus-marshal-basic.c (_dbus_type_to_string): move here from dbus-internals.c * dbus/Makefile.am: cut over from dbus-marshal.[hc] to dbus-marshal-*.[hc] * dbus/dbus-object-tree.c (_dbus_decompose_path): move this function here from dbus-marshal.c
2005-01-15 07:15:38 +00:00
- the "break loader" and valid/invalid message tests are all disabled;
they need to be fixed and re-enabled with the new message args stuff.
I think I want to drop the .message files thing and just have code
that generates messages, more like the tests for
dbus-marshal-recursive.c
- modify the auth protocol to also support other initial-handshake
type of information:
Perhaps the auth protocol should be able to negotiate a protocol
version to the least-common-denominator between client and server?
Though in practice ever using this feature would be pretty tough,
since protocol probably modifies the API. But we could have it there
as a safety net.
- need to define bus behavior if you send a message to
yourself; is it an error, or allowed? If allowed,
we need to have a test for it in the test suite.
2005-01-15 Havoc Pennington <hp@redhat.com> * Land the new message args API and type system. This patch is huge, but the public API change is not really large. The set of D-BUS types has changed somewhat, and the arg "getters" are more geared toward language bindings; they don't make a copy, etc. There are also some known issues. See these emails for details on this huge patch: http://lists.freedesktop.org/archives/dbus/2004-December/001836.html http://lists.freedesktop.org/archives/dbus/2005-January/001922.html * dbus/dbus-marshal-*: all the new stuff * dbus/dbus-message.c: basically rewritten * dbus/dbus-memory.c (check_guards): with "guards" enabled, init freed blocks to be all non-nul bytes so using freed memory is less likely to work right * dbus/dbus-internals.c (_dbus_test_oom_handling): add DBUS_FAIL_MALLOC=N environment variable, so you can do DBUS_FAIL_MALLOC=0 to skip the out-of-memory checking, or DBUS_FAIL_MALLOC=10 to make it really, really, really slow and thorough. * qt/message.cpp: port to the new message args API (operator<<): use str.utf8() rather than str.unicode() (pretty sure this is right from the Qt docs?) * glib/dbus-gvalue.c: port to the new message args API * bus/dispatch.c, bus/driver.c: port to the new message args API * dbus/dbus-string.c (_dbus_string_init_const_len): initialize the "locked" flag to TRUE and align_offset to 0; I guess we never looked at these anyhow, but seems cleaner. * dbus/dbus-string.h (_DBUS_STRING_ALLOCATION_PADDING): move allocation padding macro to this header; use it to implement (_DBUS_STRING_STATIC): ability to declare a static string. * dbus/dbus-message.c (_dbus_message_has_type_interface_member): change to return TRUE if the interface is not set. * dbus/dbus-string.[hc]: move the D-BUS specific validation stuff to dbus-marshal-validate.[hc] * dbus/dbus-marshal-basic.c (_dbus_type_to_string): move here from dbus-internals.c * dbus/Makefile.am: cut over from dbus-marshal.[hc] to dbus-marshal-*.[hc] * dbus/dbus-object-tree.c (_dbus_decompose_path): move this function here from dbus-marshal.c
2005-01-15 07:15:38 +00:00
- add string array support back to append_args()
- validate dict entry number of fields
- just before 1.0, try a HAVE_INT64=0 build and be sure it runs
- the spec and implementation should probably require dict keys
to be basic types
2004-07-03 11:20:05 +00:00
Important for 1.0 GLib Bindings
===
- finish dbus-glib-tool support for adding introspection
data to GObject and autoexporting GObject using same
- the GLib bindings varargs take DBUS_TYPE_WHATEVER and
return stuff allocated with dbus_malloc(); should this
be made more "G" at some expense in code duplication?
You also still have to use some D-BUS functions such as
dbus_message_get_args() which takes a DBusError.
Probably we need to either fully encapsulate and hide
dbus/dbus.h, or encapsulate it slightly less e.g. no
GError. Or maybe it's as simple as "never return dbus_malloc()
memory" and just fully encapsulate the get_args() type of
stuff.
- dbus_gproxy_connect_signal() has to take a signature for the signal
so it can figure out how to invoke the callback, or we have to rely
on having introspection data.
- DBusGProxy doesn't emit "destroy" when it should
Might as Well for 1.0
===
- add dbus_message_has_path(), maybe has_member/interface
2004-11-25 Havoc Pennington <hp@redhat.com> The primary change here is to always write() once before adding the write watch, which gives us about a 10% performance increase. * dbus/dbus-transport-unix.c: a number of modifications to cope with removing messages_pending (check_write_watch): properly handle DBUS_AUTH_STATE_WAITING_FOR_MEMORY; adapt to removal of messages_pending stuff (check_read_watch): properly handle WAITING_FOR_MEMORY and AUTHENTICATED cases (unix_handle_watch): after writing, see if the write watch can be removed (unix_do_iteration): assert that write_watch/read_watch are non-NULL rather than testing that they aren't, since they aren't allowed to be NULL. check_write_watch() at the end so we add the watch if we did not finish writing (e.g. got EAGAIN) * dbus/dbus-transport-protected.h: remove messages_pending call, since it resulted in too much inefficient watch adding/removing; instead we now require that the transport user does an iteration after queueing outgoing messages, and after trying the first write() we add a write watch if we got EAGAIN or exceeded our max bytes to write per iteration setting * dbus/dbus-string.c (_dbus_string_validate_signature): add this function * dbus/dbus-server-unix.c (unix_finalize): the socket name was freed and then accessed, valgrind flagged this bug, fix it * dbus/dbus-message.c: fix several bugs where HEADER_FIELD_LAST was taken as the last valid field plus 1, where really it is equal to the last valid field. Corrects some message corruption issues. * dbus/dbus-mainloop.c: verbosity changes * dbus/dbus-keyring.c (_dbus_keyring_new_homedir): handle OOM instead of aborting in one of the test codepaths * dbus/dbus-internals.c (_dbus_verbose_real): fix a bug that caused not printing the pid ever again if a verbose was missing the newline at the end (_dbus_header_field_to_string): add HEADER_FIELD_SIGNATURE * dbus/dbus-connection.c: verbosity changes; (dbus_connection_has_messages_to_send): new function (_dbus_connection_message_sent): no longer call transport->messages_pending (_dbus_connection_send_preallocated_unlocked): do one iteration to try to write() immediately, so we can avoid the write watch. This is the core purpose of this patchset (_dbus_connection_get_dispatch_status_unlocked): if disconnected, dump the outgoing message queue, so nobody will get confused trying to send them or thinking stuff is pending to be sent * bus/test.c: verbosity changes * bus/driver.c: verbosity/assertion changes * bus/dispatch.c: a bunch of little tweaks to get it working again because this patchset changes when/where you need to block.
2004-11-26 01:53:13 +00:00
- connection_open/connection_disconnect lacks symmetry, open/close
or connect/disconnect
2005-01-15 Havoc Pennington <hp@redhat.com> * Land the new message args API and type system. This patch is huge, but the public API change is not really large. The set of D-BUS types has changed somewhat, and the arg "getters" are more geared toward language bindings; they don't make a copy, etc. There are also some known issues. See these emails for details on this huge patch: http://lists.freedesktop.org/archives/dbus/2004-December/001836.html http://lists.freedesktop.org/archives/dbus/2005-January/001922.html * dbus/dbus-marshal-*: all the new stuff * dbus/dbus-message.c: basically rewritten * dbus/dbus-memory.c (check_guards): with "guards" enabled, init freed blocks to be all non-nul bytes so using freed memory is less likely to work right * dbus/dbus-internals.c (_dbus_test_oom_handling): add DBUS_FAIL_MALLOC=N environment variable, so you can do DBUS_FAIL_MALLOC=0 to skip the out-of-memory checking, or DBUS_FAIL_MALLOC=10 to make it really, really, really slow and thorough. * qt/message.cpp: port to the new message args API (operator<<): use str.utf8() rather than str.unicode() (pretty sure this is right from the Qt docs?) * glib/dbus-gvalue.c: port to the new message args API * bus/dispatch.c, bus/driver.c: port to the new message args API * dbus/dbus-string.c (_dbus_string_init_const_len): initialize the "locked" flag to TRUE and align_offset to 0; I guess we never looked at these anyhow, but seems cleaner. * dbus/dbus-string.h (_DBUS_STRING_ALLOCATION_PADDING): move allocation padding macro to this header; use it to implement (_DBUS_STRING_STATIC): ability to declare a static string. * dbus/dbus-message.c (_dbus_message_has_type_interface_member): change to return TRUE if the interface is not set. * dbus/dbus-string.[hc]: move the D-BUS specific validation stuff to dbus-marshal-validate.[hc] * dbus/dbus-marshal-basic.c (_dbus_type_to_string): move here from dbus-internals.c * dbus/Makefile.am: cut over from dbus-marshal.[hc] to dbus-marshal-*.[hc] * dbus/dbus-object-tree.c (_dbus_decompose_path): move this function here from dbus-marshal.c
2005-01-15 07:15:38 +00:00
- protocol version in each message is pretty silly
Can Be Post 1.0
===
- The message bus internal code still says "service" for
"name", "base service" for "unique name", "activate" for
"start"; would be nice to clean up.
- Property list feature on message bus (list of properties associated
with a connection). May also include message matching rules
that involve the properties of the source or destination
connection.
- Disconnecting the remote end on invalid UTF-8 is probably not a good
idea. The definition of "valid" is slightly fuzzy. I think it might
be better to just silently "fix" the UTF-8, or perhaps return an error.
Owen says we should only validate the UTF-8 on dbus_message_get_string()
(changing get_string to have an error return, and allowing a type error
as a possible return)
- assorted _-prefixed symbols in libdbus aren't actually used by
libdbus, only by the message bus. These bloat up the library
size. Not sure how to fix, really.
- build and install the Doxygen manual in Makefile when --enable-docs
2003-05-05 19:12:58 +00:00
- if you send the same message to multiple connections, the serial number
will only be right for one of them. Probably need to just write() the serial
number, rather than putting it in the DBusMessage, or something.
- perhaps the bus driver should have properties that reflect attributes
of the session, such as hostname, architecture, operating system,
etc. Could be useful for code that wants to special-case behavior
for a particular host or class of hosts, for example.
- currently the security policy stuff for messages to/from
the bus driver is kind of strange; basically it's hardcoded that
you can always talk to the driver, but the default config file
has rules for it anyway, or something. it's conceptually
screwy at the moment.
- when making a method call, if the call serial were globally unique,
we could forward the call serial along with any method calls made
as a result of the first method call, and allow reentrancy that was
strictly part of the call stack of said method call. But I don't
really see how to do this without making the user pass around the
call serial to all method calls all the time, or disallowing
async calls.
If done post 1.0 will probably be an optional/ugly-API type
of thing.
2003-09-15 Havoc Pennington <hp@pobox.com> * dbus/dbus-pending-call.c: add the get/set object data boilerplate as for DBusConnection, etc. Use generic object data for the notify callback. * glib/dbus-gparser.c (parse_node): parse child nodes * tools/dbus-viewer.c: more hacking on the dbus-viewer * glib/dbus-gutils.c (_dbus_gutils_split_path): add a file to contain functions shared between the convenience lib and the installed lib * glib/Makefile.am (libdbus_glib_1_la_LDFLAGS): add -export-symbols-regex to the GLib library * dbus/dbus-object-tree.c (_dbus_object_tree_dispatch_and_unlock): fix the locking in here, and add a default handler for Introspect() that just returns sub-nodes. 2003-09-14 Havoc Pennington <hp@pobox.com> * glib/dbus-gthread.c (dbus_g_thread_init): rename to make g_foo rather than gfoo consistent * glib/dbus-gproxy.h: delete for now, move contents to dbus-glib.h, because the include files don't work right since we aren't in the dbus/ subdir. * glib/dbus-gproxy.c (dbus_gproxy_send): finish implementing (dbus_gproxy_end_call): finish (dbus_gproxy_begin_call): finish * glib/dbus-gmain.c (dbus_set_g_error): new * glib/dbus-gobject.c (handle_introspect): include information about child nodes in the introspection * dbus/dbus-connection.c (dbus_connection_list_registered): new function to help in implementation of introspection * dbus/dbus-object-tree.c (_dbus_object_tree_list_registered_and_unlock): new function 2003-09-12 Havoc Pennington <hp@pobox.com> * glib/dbus-gidl.h: add common base class for all the foo_info types * tools/dbus-viewer.c: add GTK-based introspection UI thingy similar to kdcop * test/Makefile.am: try test srcdir -ef . in addition to test srcdir = ., one of them should work (yeah lame) * glib/Makefile.am: build the "idl" parser stuff as a convenience library * glib/dbus-gparser.h: make description_load routines return NodeInfo* not Parser* * Makefile.am (SUBDIRS): build test dir after all library dirs * configure.in: add GTK+ detection
2003-09-17 03:52:07 +00:00
- I don't want to introduce DBusObject, but refcounting and object
data could still be factored out into an internal "base class"
perhaps.
- document the auth protocol as a set of states and transitions, and
then reimplement it in those terms
2003-10-20 Havoc Pennington <hp@redhat.com> hmm, make check is currently not passing. * doc/dbus-specification.xml: add requirement that custom type names follow the same rules as interface names. * dbus/dbus-protocol.h: change some of the byte codes, to avoid duplication and allow 'c' to be 'custom'; dict is now 'm' for 'map' * doc/dbus-specification.xml: update type codes to match dbus-protocol.h, using the ASCII byte values. Rename type NAMED to CUSTOM. Add type OBJECT_PATH to the spec. 2003-10-17 Havoc Pennington <hp@redhat.com> * bus/driver.c (create_unique_client_name): use "." as separator in base service names instead of '-' * dbus/dbus-string.c (_dbus_string_get_byte): allow getting nul byte at the end of the string * dbus/dbus-internals.h (_DBUS_LIKELY, _DBUS_UNLIKELY): add optimization macros since string validation seems to be a slow point. * doc/dbus-specification.xml: restrict valid service/interface/member/error names. Add test suite code for the name validation. * dbus/dbus-string.c: limit service/interface/member/error names to [0-9][A-Z][a-z]_ * dbus/dbus-connection.c (dbus_connection_dispatch): add missing format arg to verbose spew * glib/dbus-gproxy.c (dbus_gproxy_call_no_reply): if not out of memory, return instead of g_error * test/test-service.c (path_message_func): support emitting a signal on request * dbus/dbus-bus.c (init_connections_unlocked): only fill in activation bus type if DBUS_BUS_ACTIVATION was set; default to assuming the activation bus was the session bus so that services started manually will still register. (init_connections_unlocked): fix so that in OOM situation we get the same semantics when retrying the function * test/test-service.c (main): change to use path registration, to test those codepaths; register with DBUS_BUS_ACTIVATION rather than DBUS_BUS_SESSION
2003-10-21 05:46:52 +00:00
- recursive dispatch, see dbus_connection_dispatch()
2004-06-07 20:48:33 +00:00
- do we need per-display activation; if so I'd like to do this by setting a
"display ID" property on screen 0, with a GUID, and keying activation by
said GUID. Otherwise you get all kinds of unrobust
string/hostname-based mess. per-screen is then done by appending screen number
to the display. If displays have a deterministic ID like this, you can
do per-display by simply including GUID in the service name.
- optimization and profiling!