Remove XFAIL_TESTS from Makefile.am

The variable XFAIL_TESTS is not used anymore since commit e90073f7dd.

The description for the known failures are moved into the respective tests as
comments.

The following descriptions were dropped:

- surface-pattern-big: Didn't really explain the failure
- big-line: Test isn't failing any more
- self-intersecting: Only XFAIL on quartz, but description doesn't match this

The following tests don't have a xfail reference image and seem to fail just
because of not having a reference image at all (I kept their description for
now):

big-trap, long-lines, self-copy-overlap

Signed-off-by: Uli Schlachter <psychon@znc.in>
This commit is contained in:
Uli Schlachter 2013-09-29 13:12:55 +02:00
parent 5e6e453671
commit bc89be2fff
10 changed files with 30 additions and 73 deletions

View file

@ -142,79 +142,6 @@ surface-source.c \
testtable.js \
reference
# Any test for which the code committed to CVS is expected to fail
# should be listed here.
#
# This way, we can avoid being bothered by reports of bugs we are
# aware of, but users can still report when tests start behaving in
# unexpected ways on their system.
#
# Of course, before any "release" of cairo we should eliminate
# everything from this list by fixing the bugs. (We don't necessarily
# have to be that strict for "snapshots" though.)
#
# Analysis of XFAIL errors:
# alpha-similar - discrepancy between backends in applying color
# components of a pure alpha surface
# big-line - range overflow of fixed-point
# big-trap - range overflow of fixed-point
# degenerate-dash - needs path editing in PS to convert degenerate
# end-caps into the shapes as expected by cairo
# (Or maybe PS is the correct behaviour?)
# degenerate-path - undefined behaviour in PS, needs path editing to
# convert degenerate segments into circles/rectangles
# as expected by cairo
# device-offset-scale - complication of pre-multiplying device_offset
# into the pattern_matrix and then requiring further
# manipulation for SVG
# extend-pad - lacks implementation in pixman and consequently used
# as an excuse for lack of support in other backends
# fallback-resolution - The essential problem here is that the recording-surface
# has recorded a sequence of operations with one device
# transformation, and we attempt to replay it with
# another (basically a scale-factor for the falback
# resolution). Carl begun to look at this with his
# chain-of-bugs, but the can of worms is much bigger.
# It appears to be a design flaw in the recording-surface
# that may spread further...
# My solution would be to lock Behad and Adrian in a
# room, with Carl as a moderator and not let them out
# until they have come up with an interface and
# semantics that actually work. :-)
# in-fill-empty-trapezoid The cairo_in_fill () function can sometimes
# produce false positives when the tessellator
# produces empty trapezoids and the query
# point lands exactly on a trapezoid edge.
# long-lines - range overflow of fixed-point
# scale-offset-image - loss of precision converting a cairo matrix to
# scale-offset-similar pixman's fixed point format.
# self-copy-overlap - vector surfaces take snapshot of patterns in contrast
# to the raster backends which don't. One solution
# would be to clone overlapping areas of dst/source, so
# patterns were effectively snapshotted across all
# backends.
# self-intersecting - incremental trapezoidation of strokes can generate
# overlapping traps. Needs self-intersection analysis
# on cairo_traps_t after strokes.
# Test case should also be expanded to hit special-case
# tessellators as well.
# surface-pattern-big...- Strange, unexplained results for SVG/PS.
XFAIL_TESTS = \
alpha-similar$(EXEEXT) \
big-line$(EXEEXT) \
big-trap$(EXEEXT) \
degenerate-dash$(EXEEXT) \
degenerate-path$(EXEEXT) \
device-offset-scale$(EXEEXT) \
extend-pad$(EXEEXT) \
fallback-resolution$(EXEEXT) \
in-fill-empty-trapezoid$(EXEEXT) \
long-lines$(EXEEXT) \
self-copy-overlap$(EXEEXT) \
self-intersecting$(EXEEXT) \
surface-pattern-big-scale-down$(EXEEXT) \
$(NULL)
# Any test that doesn't generate a log file goes here
NOLOG_TESTS = \
fallback-resolution \

View file

@ -60,6 +60,10 @@ draw (cairo_t *cr, int width, int height)
return CAIRO_TEST_SUCCESS;
}
/*
* XFAIL: discrepancy between backends in applying color components of a pure
* alpha surface
*/
CAIRO_TEST (alpha_similar,
"Tests creation of similar alpha surfaces"
"\nApplication of a pure-alpha similar source is inconsistent across backends.",

View file

@ -82,6 +82,7 @@ draw (cairo_t *cr, int width, int height)
return CAIRO_TEST_SUCCESS;
}
/* XFAIL: range overflow of fixed-point */
CAIRO_TEST (big_trap,
"Test oversize trapezoid with a clip region"
"\nTest needs to be adjusted to trigger the original bug",

View file

@ -77,6 +77,11 @@ draw (cairo_t *cr, int width, int height)
return CAIRO_TEST_SUCCESS;
}
/*
* XFAIL: needs path editing in PS to convert degenerate
* end-caps into the shapes as expected by cairo (Or maybe PS is the correct
* behaviour?)
*/
CAIRO_TEST (degenerate_dash,
"Tests the behaviour of dashed segments that end on a off-on transition",
"dash, degenerate", /* keywords */

View file

@ -108,6 +108,10 @@ draw (cairo_t *cr, int width, int height)
return CAIRO_TEST_SUCCESS;
}
/*
* XFAIL: undefined behaviour in PS, needs path editing to convert degenerate
* segments into circles/rectangles as expected by cairo
*/
CAIRO_TEST (degenerate_path,
"Tests the behaviour of degenerate paths with different cap types",
"degenerate", /* keywords */

View file

@ -65,6 +65,10 @@ draw (cairo_t *cr, int width, int height)
return CAIRO_TEST_SUCCESS;
}
/*
* XFAIL: complication of pre-multiplying device_offset into the pattern_matrix
* and then requiring further manipulation for SVG
*/
CAIRO_TEST (device_offset_scale,
"Test that the device-offset transform is transformed by the ctm.",
"device-offset", /* keywords */

View file

@ -96,6 +96,11 @@ preamble (cairo_test_context_t *ctx)
return ret;
}
/*
* XFAIL: The cairo_in_fill () function can sometimes produce false positives
* when the tessellator produces empty trapezoids and the query point lands
* exactly on a trapezoid edge.
*/
CAIRO_TEST (in_fill_empty_trapezoid,
"Test that the tessellator isn't producing obviously empty trapezoids",
"in, trap", /* keywords */

View file

@ -74,6 +74,7 @@ draw (cairo_t *cr, int width, int height)
return CAIRO_TEST_SUCCESS;
}
/* XFAIL: range overflow of fixed-point */
CAIRO_TEST (long_lines,
"Test long lines"
"\nLong lines are not drawn due to the limitations of the internal 16.16 fixed-point coordinates",

View file

@ -133,6 +133,7 @@ draw (cairo_t *cr, int width, int height)
return CAIRO_TEST_SUCCESS;
}
/* XFAIL: loss of precision converting a cairo matrix to */
CAIRO_TEST (scale_offset_image,
"Tests drawing surfaces under various scales and transforms",
"surface, scale-offset", /* keywords */

View file

@ -40,6 +40,11 @@ draw (cairo_t *cr, int width, int height)
return CAIRO_TEST_SUCCESS;
}
/*
* XFAIL: vector surfaces take snapshot of patterns in contrast to the raster
* backends which don't. One solution would be to clone overlapping areas of
* dst/source, so patterns were effectively snapshotted across all backends.
*/
CAIRO_TEST (self_copy_overlap,
"Tests painting to itself using itself as the source"
"\nBackends treat this case inconsistently---vector backends are creating snapshots.",